Football clubs or media/content companies?
Raymond Boyle and Richard Haynes wrote in 2004 that digital innovation has disrupted the traditional broadcast model and that consumers have more power now. “The virtual fan no longer leans back but now leans forward to get a more immersive and interactive experience". Football clubs should look at – investigating if you don’t have an idea at the moment – fan (consumer) preferences and respond to that which Ian Lawrence also wrote in his book Football Club Management: Insights from the Field.
So, football clubs are more and more shifting towards media or content companies. In an article on Digiday: https://digiday.com/marketing/reality-content-company-football-clubs-embrace-role-digital-publisher/ you read that it could be about erasing geographical boundaries and monetizing your audience (on owned platforms or thinking of sponsorship models).
FC Barcelona recently shared their new digital vision: https://www.fcbarcelona.com/en/news/1601557/barcas-digital-strategy-creates-new-relationship-with-fans-in-order-to-adapt-to-changing-consumer-habits and mentioned that from their 350 million followers social media wide only a fraction will visit the stadium, museum or Barça stores in person. Through their new vision, investments in technology and content production they want to make sure that ‘the vast majority who may never be able to see the ground in person still feel close to the Club and feel like they are members of the Barça family’ (Digital Vision 2020).
On the monetizing aspect you could read an article on The Drum (2017): https://www.thedrum.com/news/2017/05/19/blurring-the-lines-how-football-clubs-manchester-united-are-evolving-media-owners outlining Manchester United’s investments in developing its MUTV channel.
In a piece on SportBusiness: https://www.sportbusiness.com/news/barca-expects-sponsorship-gains-from-new-digital-strategy/, head of FC Barcelona digital area Dídac Lee said the following: “The fact that we know our fans better through data and have new products and services to connect with them, gives our partners the possibility to be much more relevant for those audiences in our fanbase that are most relevant to them.” As a club, you should of course make sure that you have that data available (is it then looking at new technology or looking how you currently work and what’s possible with the current set-up). A reminder is that’s it not about the amount of data you have but the quality of the data.
There is a saying that content is king (and engagement queen) and fans – I’m saying this with myself in mind and you can’t make any assumptions without investigating this – want to get that content, is it from training sessions, the arrival of the team, interviews, sharing thoughts etc. You can bring that ‘in the moment’ or you can work on content like we saw with Manchester City and their documentary All or Nothing on Amazon (and thinking again of an extra revenue stream). It’s not just football of course, big sporting franchises like NFL, NBA and UFC all want to get more control of their own content and fulfilling their potential through their collected data.
Now I hear you thinking, it’s easy for big clubs like FC Barcelona, Manchester United and others because they have the money and they have the following. And yes, that’s true of course but it’s also about principles, about being creative, about focussing on your own situation. When you’re a smaller club you probably don’t need to have that one technology package with all bells and whistles, there’s such a big landscape and you will probably find something matching your needs. Mentioning digital transformation here as it’s such a hot topic now, but you shouldn’t forget that it’s still about people, about creating an innovative and open culture, technology is ‘just’ an enabler.
There’s so much more to touch upon, but would like to briefly mention this:
- Going further on the last point, while technology can be great, we shouldn’t forget about the human touch. Thinking for instance about the role of SLOs (Supporter Liaison Officers) and engaging fan groups before, during and after a game. Be sure to read some SLO interviews on the SD Europe website: https://www.sdeurope.eu/slo-of-the-month-jp-taylor-of-celtic-fc/ and to look at the great work people like Mark Bradley from the Fan Experience Company are doing. Take some time to listen to this podcast on how to create a fan experience strategy with Mark: http://www.mrrichardclarke.com/sportdigitalandsocial/bradley
- Repeating again that you should look at your specific situation and investigate about preferences and openness/willingness from your fanbase to adopt new technologies. Consultancy company Capgemini found that there are significant regional differences in acceptance, Asia being the most receptive to innovation and Europe a bit less: https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevemccaskill/2020/02/21/tech-is-revenue-opportunity-for-sports-organizations-but-european-fans-less-receptive/. The last years I’ve heard it several times, having two sides where one side is looking and focussing on technology and innovation and the other side saying it should go back to the basics which is the game and the action on the pitch.
- A very interesting topic is the whole focus nowadays on subscription models. We all know that big media outlets are creating those pay walls and you have The Athletic for instance embracing the subscription model completely and bringing the message of offering in-depth content you wouldn’t find anywhere else. On the other hand you have stories like that from OTRO dropping the subscription model just seven months after their launch: https://www.broadcastnow.co.uk/broadcasting/football-platform-otro-drops-paywall/5141651.article. A ‘new’ term popping up together with all the subscription models is subscription fatigue. You have a bunch of streaming services (not only in sports of course) all fighting for a piece of the cake and we hear announcements like “Premflix” and the attached question if we’re reaching saturation: https://www.forbes.com/sites/chriswilliams/2020/02/10/premier-league-okays-netflix-style-service-but-are-we-reaching-ott-saturation/
As said, we’re seeing media outlets investigating and implementing the best registration journeys, but as Bas Schnater mentioned on Twitter, in sports it’s still a bit of an untapped area. Read this Twitter thread: https://twitter.com/BasSchnater/status/1227202040062935041.
Still an untapped area in sports, but in media there's a major shift happening of publishers moving from anonymous content readers to registered content readers. Registered users are 10x more likely to convert than anonymous users https://t.co/cd58YanlsGpic.twitter.com/bKcSuRlw29
— Bas Schnater ⚽??? (@BasSchnater) February 11, 2020
FC Barcelona (yes again) and also their big rival Real Madrid have launched together with Facebook a subscription service on the platform. For a small amount per month you can get exclusive content, badges, stickers and exclusive prizes. This opened then a discussion if you should focus on such models or have your own platforms in place.
In a previous blog I mentioned the report from we are social and the big scale of social media use worldwide. According to Result Sport, FC Barcelona has the biggest following (a small note that the 350 million figure mentioned earlier includes all club channels like youth football, professional sections, Foundation, etc.) before Real Madrid and Manchester United.

Cover photo by Andres Urena on Unsplash